Buttermilk Pie: A Classic Southern Dessert You’ll Love

If you’re searching for a dessert that’s both creamy and comforting, buttermilk pie is a timeless choice that never disappoints. This old-fashioned Southern favorite has been warming hearts and tables for generations. Its custardy texture, balanced sweetness, and subtle tang from buttermilk make it uniquely delicious. Whether you’re baking for a holiday, a casual family dinner, or simply craving something nostalgic, buttermilk pie is a crowd-pleaser that’s easy to make and truly satisfying.

In this article, you’ll learn everything you need to know to create the perfect buttermilk pie—from the ingredients that bring it to life, to tips on baking and serving. Plus, we’ll explore some creative twists to keep this classic fresh.

What Is Buttermilk Pie?

Buttermilk pie is a custard-style pie that uses buttermilk as a primary ingredient, giving it a creamy, slightly tangy flavor. Unlike chess pie, which includes cornmeal, or lemon meringue pie with its tart lemon curd, buttermilk pie relies on simple pantry staples and the richness of buttermilk to shine.

Print

Originating in the Southern United States, buttermilk pie has deep roots in traditional home cooking. It’s known for its smooth, silky filling set in a flaky pie crust and lightly spiced with vanilla and nutmeg. The pie’s sweet but tangy profile makes it an ideal finish to any meal.

Ingredients and Their Roles

Understanding the role of each ingredient helps you appreciate how they work together to create buttermilk pie’s signature taste and texture:

• Eggs: Provide structure and help the custard set as it bakes, resulting in a firm yet creamy filling.
• Sugar: Sweetens the pie and helps with caramelization of the top during baking.
• Butter: Adds richness and depth of flavor, contributing to a smooth mouthfeel.
• All-purpose flour: Acts as a thickening agent to stabilize the custard and prevent it from being too runny.
• Buttermilk: The star ingredient, bringing a mild tang and tenderizing effect, balancing the sweetness.
• Lemon juice: Adds a subtle brightness that complements the tang of the buttermilk and cuts through the richness.
• Vanilla extract: Provides warm, aromatic undertones that enhance the overall flavor.
• Nutmeg: This gentle spice brings a subtle warmth and aromatic depth to the pie, enhancing the custard’s flavor without overpowering it.
• Pie crust: Typically a 9-inch deep-dish unbaked pie shell that holds the custard filling, flaky and buttery for the perfect contrast.

Step-by-Step Instructions to Make Buttermilk Pie

Preparation

Start by gathering all your ingredients. Preheat your oven to 350°F (175°C). This moderate heat ensures the custard bakes evenly without curdling or cracking.

Mixing the Custard

In a large mixing bowl, beat 3 large eggs until they become frothy—this introduces air and helps the filling become light. Add 1 ½ cups of sugar, ½ cup softened butter, and 3 tablespoons of all-purpose flour. Beat the mixture well until smooth and creamy.

Next, stir in 1 cup of buttermilk, 1 tablespoon of fresh lemon juice, 1 teaspoon of vanilla extract, and ⅛ teaspoon of freshly grated nutmeg. Combine thoroughly to distribute the flavors evenly throughout the custard.

Assembling the Pie

Pour the prepared custard mixture into your unbaked deep-dish 9-inch pie crust. Use a glass or metal pie plate to ensure even baking.

Baking

Position the pie on the center rack of your heated oven and bake for 40 to 60 minutes. The exact time will depend on your oven and the thickness of your crust. The pie is ready when the center is firm and doesn’t wobble when gently shaken. The surface should take on a soft golden color as it finishes baking.

Cooling and Serving

Remove the pie from the oven and allow it to cool completely—at least one hour—so the filling firms up for clean slicing. Buttermilk pie is delicious served at room temperature or chilled, often topped with freshly whipped cream and a light dusting of nutmeg for an extra touch.

Tips for the Perfect Buttermilk Pie

• Use room temperature eggs and butter: This helps ingredients blend smoothly and promotes even baking.
• Don’t overmix the flour: Overworking flour can make the filling tough; mix just until combined.
• Watch the baking time: Start checking at 40 minutes to avoid overbaking. The pie should be set but still creamy.
• Cool gradually: Avoid drastic temperature changes to prevent cracking. Let it cool at room temperature before refrigerating.
• Pre-bake your crust (optional): For a crisper crust, blind bake it for 8–10 minutes before adding filling.

Delicious Variations to Try

• Try a pinch of cinnamon — It introduces a cozy, sweet-spice flavor that pairs beautifully with the gentle warmth of nutmeg.
• Use orange juice instead of lemon — This subtle swap brings a softer, sweeter citrus note that brightens the pie in a new way.
• Make mini pies or tartlets: Perfect for individual servings or parties.
• Drizzle caramel or honey: For extra sweetness and depth.

Nutritional Information

Per slice (based on 8 servings):

• Calories: ~413
• Total Fat: 21g
• Saturated Fat: 10g
• Cholesterol: 102mg
• Sodium: 257mg
• Carbohydrates: 52g
• Dietary Fiber: 1g
• Sugars: 39g
• Protein: 5g
• Vitamin C: 1mg
• Calcium: 52mg
• Iron: 1mg
• Potassium: 96mg

While this dessert is indulgent, enjoying it in moderation within a balanced diet is perfectly fine—especially when paired with fresh fruit or a light cup of coffee.

Serving Suggestions

Buttermilk pie pairs wonderfully with:

• Top each slice with a spoonful of soft whipped cream or a bit of crème fraîche for added richness.
• Dust lightly with ground cinnamon or nutmeg to enhance the warm, spiced notes.
• Serve alongside fresh berries or a simple berry compote for a bright, fruity contrast.
• Pair with a hot cup of coffee or tea to complement the pie’s sweetness and round out the dessert.

This pie also shines as a dessert for holidays, potlucks, or casual weekend gatherings.

Storing and Freezing Buttermilk Pie

• Storage: Keep leftovers covered in the refrigerator for up to 3-4 days.
• Freezing: Wrap the pie securely in plastic wrap followed by a layer of foil, and freeze for up to two months. When ready to enjoy, let it thaw in the refrigerator overnight for the best texture and flavor.
• Reheating: Warm slices gently in a microwave or oven if desired, but it’s also excellent served chilled.

Final Thoughts

Buttermilk pie is a classic dessert that combines the simplicity of basic ingredients with a rich, creamy texture and bright, tangy flavor. It’s a comforting, nostalgic treat that’s easy enough for beginner bakers yet impressive enough to serve to guests. Whether you enjoy it fresh, chilled, or topped with whipped cream, this pie embodies the warmth and tradition of Southern cooking.

Give this recipe a try, and you’ll quickly understand why buttermilk pie has stood the test of time as a beloved dessert. Perfect for any occasion, it’s a sweet slice of history that never goes out of style.